Comparing 11 Models by Real Token Cost After the August 31 Repricing: Peak Hours, Cache Hits, and Tokenizer Effects
A model's list price wears at least three more layers. Time of day: DeepSeek moved to peak and off-peak pricing on August 17, charging peak rates on weekdays from 09:00-12:00 and 14:00-18:00, halving them off-peak, and applying off-peak rates all weekend, so the same model costs twice as much at 3pm as at 10pm. Caching: prefix cache hits are billed far below standard input, and the variable sits with your prompt structure rather than the vendor. Tokenization: Sonnet 5 changed tokenizers, so the same input now maps to 1.0x to 1.35x more tokens, and the multiplier floats with content type. This comparison fixes one unit throughout, blended rate equals input plus output divided by two, assuming equal token volumes, as a neutral starting point, then recalculates under three realistic load profiles across 11 models, covering list price, cached input, peak and off-peak, and post-tokenizer position. The finding is not which model is cheapest, it is that no model is cheapest, only cheapest for your particular load: any comparison that ignores input-output ratio, cache hit rate, and content type is comparing list prices, not costs. Chinese model prices come from a page-by-page check of official pricing pages on 2026-08-24, re-confirmed on 08-28; overseas prices from a 2026-08-31 roundup. Conflicts are flagged per line. No live benchmarking was performed.